Planning a blasting cleanup in Wisconsin? This guide covers the rules that apply to spent coal slag, the tests that decide how it can be managed, and what DNR needs before the material can be reused.
Key terms
Coal slag abrasive
Coal slag is a glassy byproduct of coal-fired boilers. It is crushed and graded for use as blasting media.
Spent media
Spent media is the abrasive after blasting. It is mixed with paint, rust, coatings, and substrate debris. Its regulatory status depends on that mix, not on the unused abrasive.
Beneficial reuse
Beneficial reuse puts a waste material to productive use instead of disposing of it. Wisconsin’s rule calls it “beneficial use”: using an industrial byproduct in a productive manner.
TCLP
The Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (EPA Method 1311) measures how much of certain contaminants can leach from a sample. It is one part of deciding whether a waste is hazardous.
What’s in your spent media?
After blasting, coal slag is mixed with whatever came off the surface. That collected material needs its own evaluation. The data sheet for unused slag only describes the starting abrasive.
Coatings matter most. Lead-based paint, chromate primers, and other metal-bearing coatings can make spent media hazardous even when the abrasive itself is not. Keep track of the abrasive and the surfaces blasted. Keep wet-blasting sludge and wash water separate from dry residue.
Wisconsin’s beneficial use rule
Wisconsin’s beneficial use rule is ch. NR 538, Beneficial Use of Industrial Byproducts. Its listed byproducts include coal combustion residuals such as boiler slag. It also covers nonhazardous solid waste with similar characteristics, as DNR determines (NR 538.03(8)).
Two limits matter for spent media. An industrial byproduct must be generated by an industrial process and have consistent physical and chemical properties. Hazardous waste is excluded. Spent media carries coating and substrate debris, so DNR decides whether it qualifies.
Byproducts characterized and used under NR 538 are exempt from solid waste licensing and from chs. NR 500 to 528 (NR 538.05). NR 538.10 groups eligible uses as contained or converted uses, geotechnical fill, construction uses, unconfined uses, and soil or plant additives.
DNR may approve uses case by case under NR 538.09. If DNR finds a material is not an industrial byproduct, reuse needs DNR’s written approval under s. NR 500.08(5) and s. 289.43, Wis. Stats.
Certifying with DNR
- Who files: the generator or the generator’s designee.
- How: characterize the material under NR 538.06 and report the results on the Initial Certification, Form 4400-197. Include documentation supporting the hazardous waste determination.
- Scope: file an initial certification for any byproduct not previously approved for eligible uses, for any byproduct whose generating process has changed, and before setting up a storage facility.
- Review: DNR replies within 10 business days. It may concur, ask for more information, require a case-specific approval, or not concur. If DNR does not respond within 10 business days, concurrence is considered granted.
- After concurrence: many eligible uses can proceed without specific approval. Some geotechnical fill projects need written notice on Form 4400-199 and DNR concurrence first.
- Reporting: report the previous year’s beneficial use to DNR by April 1, online or on Form 4400-198.
- Liquids: after water blasting, separate paint chips and other solids from the water. The water needs its own waste determination.
DNR beneficial use program: dnrbeneficialusereporting@wisconsin.gov.
Hazardous waste determination
Wisconsin’s hazardous waste rules are chs. NR 660 to 679 of the Wisconsin Administrative Code. Their section numbers track 40 CFR. The toxicity characteristic is NR 661.0024.
DNR guidance addresses blasting waste directly. Abrasive blasting waste from water towers, bridges, and other commercial, industrial, and municipal structures is solid waste and may be hazardous waste. Used blasting material from paint removal may contain heavy metals above the RCRA limit, so test a representative sample with TCLP. Supplier claims that media is nonhazardous do not account for paint chips, so you still must make a waste determination.
Under Wis. Admin. Code NR 662.011, the generator must decide whether spent media is hazardous:
- Make the determination at the point of generation, before mixing or dilution. Repeat it if the waste may have changed.
- Check whether the waste is excluded from the hazardous waste rules.
- Check whether it matches a listed hazardous waste.
- Check for hazardous characteristics, including toxicity. Use knowledge of the materials and process, testing, or both. Test when knowledge alone is not enough.
Small and large quantity generators must keep records supporting the determination for at least three years after the waste was last sent for treatment, storage, or disposal.
TCLP testing and limits
Tell the lab what you blasted and what might be in the debris. Use representative samples. Agree on the sampling plan with the lab, DNR, and the receiving site before collecting.
A waste is hazardous for toxicity if its TCLP extract meets or exceeds any limit in 40 CFR 261.24. The metals most relevant to coating debris are:
| Contaminant | EPA waste code | Limit (mg/L) |
|---|---|---|
| Arsenic | D004 | 5.0 |
| Barium | D005 | 100.0 |
| Cadmium | D006 | 1.0 |
| Chromium | D007 | 5.0 |
| Lead | D008 | 5.0 |
| Mercury | D009 | 0.2 |
| Selenium | D010 | 1.0 |
| Silver | D011 | 5.0 |
Passing TCLP addresses toxicity for the substances tested. It does not approve reuse or rule out other reasons a waste may be hazardous.
NR 538 adds its own characterization. Test a representative sample with a bulk analysis and the ASTM D3987-12 water leach test, and compare the results with the NR 538 Appendix standards.
Finding a reuse destination
DNR decides whether spent media fits NR 538 and which uses are eligible. Check any destination and proposed use with DNR before scheduling delivery.
When you talk to DNR, match the proposal to an NR 538.10 use category. Get the receiving site’s specifications and written acceptance. If reuse is not cleared, arrange disposal that fits the waste determination. DNR guidance says waste blasting material that is not hazardous can go to a licensed solid waste landfill.
Worker protection
- Lead: removing lead-based coatings falls under OSHA’s lead in construction standard, 29 CFR 1926.62.
- Beryllium: coal slag contains trace beryllium. OSHA has identified abrasive blasting as an operation where trace amounts can still cause significant exposure. See 29 CFR 1926.1124 and OSHA’s beryllium standards page.
- Dust: control dust during collection, storage, and loading.
Storage and records
Keep the material contained, control dust and runoff, and label loads by job. Keep other wastes out. Storage for beneficial use must meet NR 538.16 unless the material is held in an enclosed structure such as a building, silo, or rolloff box. Temporary off-site storage or staging is limited to 16 months, with written notice to DNR.
Keep job records, data sheets, lab reports, the waste determination, DNR concurrence, and the receiving site’s acceptance together. Record what ships and where it goes. Keep determination records for at least three years. For geotechnical fill uses, keep records of where the byproduct was used for 5 years after use.
Before pickup
- Identify the abrasive, surfaces blasted, coatings, volume, moisture, and pickup location.
- Make the hazardous waste determination and complete the required tests.
- Choose a destination and get its material specifications.
- File or confirm the DNR initial certification and concurrence for that material and use.
- Get written acceptance and arrange pickup.
Talk to ARS about your material, location, volume, and test results. We can help you work through pickup and the next steps.
Common questions
Is a passing TCLP test enough?
No. It answers a toxicity question for the substances tested. The full waste determination, DNR approval, and the receiving site’s specifications still apply.
Can I use the original abrasive’s data sheet?
Keep it as background, but test or otherwise characterize the collected material. Blasting adds coatings and debris that the original data sheet does not cover.
Who files the certification?
The generator or the generator’s designee. ARS can help gather the material information.
Can I use another project’s concurrence?
Not on its own. File an initial certification for any byproduct not previously approved, or whose generating process has changed. If byproducts are mixed, each must be eligible for the final use unless DNR approves otherwise in writing.
How long can spent media be staged before use?
Temporary off-site storage or staging for beneficial use is limited to 16 months after placement. Other storage must meet NR 538.16 unless the material is enclosed.
When do we need to test again?
Recharacterize at least every 4 years, and whenever a process change could change the eligible uses. The 4-year retest is not required for a byproduct with less than 1,000 cubic yards used or stored for use in any calendar year of the previous 4 years.
Rules and guidance
- Wisconsin DNR: Beneficial use of industrial byproducts
- Ch. NR 538: Beneficial Use of Industrial Byproducts
- NR 500.08(5): Beneficial reuse exemptions
- DNR Form 4400-197: Initial Certification
- DNR WA-173: Commercial and Residential Paint Removal and Disposal
- DNR WA-299: Spray Painting and Coating Operations
- NR 662.011: Hazardous waste determination and recordkeeping
- Ch. NR 661: Hazardous Waste Identification and Listing
- 40 CFR 262.11: Hazardous waste determination
- 40 CFR 261.24: Toxicity characteristic
- EPA Method 1311: TCLP
- EPA: Defining Hazardous Waste
- OSHA 29 CFR 1926.62: Lead in construction
- OSHA 29 CFR 1926.1124: Beryllium in construction