Planning a blasting cleanup in North Dakota? This guide covers the rules that apply to spent coal slag, the tests that decide how it can be managed, and what DEQ needs before the material can be reused.
Key terms
Coal slag abrasive
Coal slag is a glassy byproduct of coal-fired boilers. It is crushed and graded for use as blasting media.
Spent media
Spent media is the abrasive after blasting. It is mixed with paint, rust, coatings, and substrate debris. Its regulatory status depends on that mix, not on the unused abrasive.
Beneficial reuse
Beneficial reuse puts a waste material to productive use instead of disposing of it. North Dakota’s rules call this “beneficial use.” DEQ authorizes it through general permits.
TCLP
The Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (EPA Method 1311) measures how much of certain contaminants can leach from a sample. It is one part of deciding whether a waste is hazardous.
What’s in your spent media?
After blasting, coal slag is mixed with whatever came off the surface. That collected material needs its own evaluation. The data sheet for unused slag only describes the starting abrasive.
Coatings matter most. Lead-based paint, chromate primers, and other metal-bearing coatings can make spent media hazardous even when the abrasive itself is not. Keep track of the abrasive and the surfaces blasted. Keep wet-blasting sludge and wash water separate from dry residue.
North Dakota’s beneficial use rule
North Dakota defines beneficial use in NDAC 33.1-20-01.1-03. It is use of a solid waste in a manufacturing process to make a product, or as a substitute for a raw material or product, without harm to health or the environment. The use must:
- provide a functional benefit;
- substitute for a virgin material; and
- meet relevant product specifications, regulatory standards, or design standards. Where none exist, the material may not be used in excess quantities.
The beneficial use rule is NDAC 33.1-20-02.1-03. DEQ may issue general permits, regional or statewide, for a category of beneficial use. The wastes must come from the same or similar operations and have similar physical and chemical makeup. Using the waste as an ingredient or product substitute may not present more harm than the material it replaces.
You do not need an individual solid waste permit if you follow an applicable general permit and register when it requires registration. DEQ may still require an individual permit when a person does not comply or the activity may cause harm.
Inert waste has its own route. DEQ Guideline 38 excludes industrial solid waste, special waste, hazardous waste, ash, and debris from inert waste beneficial use. It notes that material exposed to lead or other contaminants may not be suitable.
DEQ may also approve a solid waste pilot project under NDAC 33.1-20-02.1-10. Get written approval before you start. A pilot project may not last more than two years.
Applying to DEQ
- Who files: any person may apply for a new general permit. DEQ may also issue one on its own.
- How: apply on a DEQ form and pay the fee in NDAC chapter 33.1-20-15.
- Contents: describe the waste, with enough sample analyses to show its range of physical and chemical properties. Describe the proposed use and the process that makes the waste, with a diagram.
- Limits: propose contaminant concentration limits and explain why they are protective.
- Suitability: show the waste helps the use and meets the standards for the material it replaces. Roadway uses need Department of Transportation approval, if applicable.
- Land placement: construction material, soil substitute, antiskid, and other land uses need an evaluation of health and environmental impacts. Cover exposure through groundwater, surface water, air, and the food chain.
- Review: DEQ posts notice once the application is substantially complete. It follows the same review and public notice procedures as for individual permits.
- Coverage: a general permit may require registration or an application, including site approval, before you start. For construction material or land placement, DEQ may require prior authorization.
- Term: each general permit has a fixed term of no more than ten years.
- After approval: DEQ may amend, suspend, or revoke coverage for noncompliance.
DEQ Division of Waste Management: 701-328-5166, solidwaste@nd.gov.
Hazardous waste determination
North Dakota’s hazardous waste rules are in NDAC Article 33.1-24. The toxicity characteristic is NDAC 33.1-24-02-14.
Two state rules stand out. Waste testing for the determination must be done by a laboratory approved under DEQ’s certification procedures. Small and large quantity generators need an identification number and a DEQ registration certificate before they store, ship, or dispose of hazardous waste.
Under NDAC 33.1-24-03-02, the generator must decide whether spent media is hazardous:
- Make the determination at the point of generation, before mixing or dilution. Repeat it if the waste may have changed.
- Check whether the waste is excluded from the hazardous waste rules.
- Check whether it matches a listed hazardous waste.
- Check for hazardous characteristics, including toxicity. Use knowledge of the materials and process, testing, or both.
North Dakota requires generators to keep determination records for at least 3 years.
TCLP testing and limits
Tell the lab what you blasted and what might be in the debris. Use representative samples. Agree on the sampling plan with the lab, DEQ, and the receiving site before collecting.
A waste is hazardous for toxicity if its TCLP extract meets or exceeds any limit in 40 CFR 261.24. The metals most relevant to coating debris are:
| Contaminant | EPA waste code | Limit (mg/L) |
|---|---|---|
| Arsenic | D004 | 5.0 |
| Barium | D005 | 100.0 |
| Cadmium | D006 | 1.0 |
| Chromium | D007 | 5.0 |
| Lead | D008 | 5.0 |
| Mercury | D009 | 0.2 |
| Selenium | D010 | 1.0 |
| Silver | D011 | 5.0 |
Passing TCLP addresses toxicity for the substances tested. It does not approve reuse or rule out other reasons a waste may be hazardous.
Under NDAC 33.1-20-01.1-12, DEQ may require treatment of a solid waste whose lab extract or leachate exceeds 20 percent of a toxicity standard in NDAC 33.1-24-02-14.
Finding a reuse destination
DEQ authorizes beneficial use through general permits. Check any destination and proposed use with DEQ before scheduling delivery.
When you talk to DEQ, show how the use meets the definition: a functional benefit, a substitute for virgin material, and the relevant specifications. Match the proposal to an existing general permit, or apply for a new one. Get the receiving site’s specifications and written acceptance. If reuse is not cleared, arrange disposal that fits the waste determination.
Worker protection
- Lead: removing lead-based coatings falls under OSHA’s lead in construction standard, 29 CFR 1926.62.
- Beryllium: coal slag contains trace beryllium. OSHA has identified abrasive blasting as an operation where trace amounts can still cause significant exposure. See 29 CFR 1926.1124 and OSHA’s beryllium standards page.
- Dust: control dust during collection, storage, and loading.
Storage and records
Keep the material contained, control dust and runoff, and label loads by job. Keep other wastes out. Material used under a general permit must stay within the permit’s physical and chemical limits. Tell DEQ right away if its properties change, including leachability.
Keep job records, data sheets, lab reports, the waste determination, DEQ approvals, and the receiving site’s acceptance together. Record what ships and where it goes. A general permit may require periodic reports and waste analyses. Keep determination records for at least three years.
Before pickup
- Identify the abrasive, surfaces blasted, coatings, volume, moisture, and pickup location.
- Make the hazardous waste determination and complete the required tests.
- Choose a destination and get its material specifications.
- Confirm coverage under a DEQ general permit, or apply for a new one.
- Get written acceptance and arrange pickup.
Talk to ARS about your material, location, volume, and test results. We can help you work through pickup and the next steps.
Common questions
Is a passing TCLP test enough?
No. It answers a toxicity question for the substances tested. The full waste determination, DEQ approval, and the receiving site’s specifications still apply.
Can I use the original abrasive’s data sheet?
Keep it as background, but test or otherwise characterize the collected material. Blasting adds coatings and debris that the original data sheet does not cover.
Can I use another project’s approval?
Only if your waste and use fit that general permit’s category and limits. The person operating under a general permit must prove the waste and activity are consistent with it.
Can spent media go through the inert waste route?
Not under Guideline 38. It excludes industrial solid waste, special waste, hazardous waste, ash, and debris from inert waste beneficial use.
How long does a general permit last?
Each general permit has a fixed term of no more than ten years from its effective date. Coverage under it ends if DEQ revokes the permit or your coverage.
When do we need to test again?
Repeat the determination when the waste may have changed. Ask about retesting when the abrasive, coating, substrate, or process changes, and follow any schedule in the general permit.
Rules and guidance
- NDAC 33.1-20-02.1: Permit Provisions and Procedures (general permits for beneficial use)
- NDAC 33.1-20-01.1: Solid Waste General Provisions (definitions)
- DEQ Guideline 38: Beneficial Use of Inert Waste
- NDAC 33.1-24-02: Identification and Listing of Hazardous Waste
- NDAC 33.1-24-03: Standards for Generators
- 40 CFR 262.11: Hazardous waste determination
- 40 CFR 261.24: Toxicity characteristic
- EPA Method 1311: TCLP
- EPA: Defining Hazardous Waste
- OSHA 29 CFR 1926.62: Lead in construction
- OSHA 29 CFR 1926.1124: Beryllium in construction