Planning a blasting cleanup in New York? This guide covers the rules that apply to spent coal slag, the tests that decide how it can be managed, and what DEC needs before the material can be reused.
Key terms
Coal slag abrasive
Coal slag is a glassy byproduct of coal-fired boilers. It is crushed and graded for use as blasting media.
Spent media
Spent media is the abrasive after blasting. It is mixed with paint, rust, coatings, and substrate debris. Its regulatory status depends on that mix, not on the unused abrasive.
Beneficial reuse
Beneficial reuse puts a waste material to productive use instead of disposing of it. New York calls DEC’s approval a beneficial use determination (BUD). Once DEC grants a BUD, the material stops being solid waste when used as the BUD describes.
TCLP
The Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (EPA Method 1311) measures how much of certain contaminants can leach from a sample. It is one part of deciding whether a waste is hazardous.
What’s in your spent media?
After blasting, coal slag is mixed with whatever came off the surface. That collected material needs its own evaluation. The data sheet for unused slag only describes the starting abrasive.
Coatings matter most. Lead-based paint, chromate primers, and other metal-bearing coatings can make spent media hazardous even when the abrasive itself is not. Keep track of the abrasive and the surfaces blasted. Keep wet-blasting sludge and wash water separate from dry residue.
New York’s beneficial use rule
New York’s rule is 6 NYCRR 360.12. It covers wastes used as effective substitutes for commercial products or raw materials. It does not apply to waste used in a way that amounts to disposal.
There are two routes:
- Predetermined BUDs: section 360.12(c) lists specific materials and uses, such as coal combustion fly ash in concrete products and bottom ash as aggregate. A material used exactly as listed is not solid waste.
- Case-specific BUDs: for other uses, file a written petition. These are generally for waste used to make a product or as a substitute for a commercial product.
DEC grants a case-specific BUD only when:
- the petition has all the required technical information;
- the use is truly use, not disposal;
- the waste is managed as a commodity and works as an effective substitute for a commercial product or raw material;
- it needs no decontamination or other processing at the point of use;
- a market exists, or is reasonably certain, for the quantity proposed;
- heavy metals and other pollutants are at levels DEC accepts for the use; and
- the use will not significantly harm public health or the environment.
DEC sets the point where the material stops being waste. Unless DEC says otherwise, that is when it is received for use. DEC may require a permit instead of a BUD for some land placement.
Petitioning DEC
- Who files: the generator or the potential end user signs the petition. A third party may sign only if it shows it will manage the material for the life of the BUD.
- How: use DEC’s Beneficial Use Determination Petition – General form, or the cement kiln feedstock or fill and cover form when it fits.
- What to include: the waste and proposed use, the annual quantity, and the process it came from. Add analytical data for the waste and the product it replaces. Show that the use meets industry or government specifications and that a market exists.
- Waste control plan: describe periodic testing, the storage type and maximum volume, run-on and run-off controls, and steps to keep the waste from spreading.
- Review: DEC responds in writing that the BUD is granted, denied, or incomplete. Review time depends on completeness and complexity.
- After approval: a case-specific BUD lasts no more than five years. Ask in writing, with a justification, to renew it. File an annual report by March 1 for the prior year.
DEC Bureau of Solid Waste Management: (518) 402-8678, benuse@dec.ny.gov.
Hazardous waste determination
New York writes its own hazardous waste rules in 6 NYCRR Parts 370 through 374 and 376. Section 370.1(e) incorporates 40 CFR Parts 260 through 266, 268, 270, 271, and 279 as revised July 1, 2014.
New York lists PCB wastes as hazardous. Under 6 NYCRR 371.4(e), any solid waste with 50 ppm or more PCBs (dry weight) is a listed hazardous waste. PCB-contaminated solids carry DEC code B007. Check old coatings for PCBs.
Under 6 NYCRR 372.2(a)(2), the generator must decide whether spent media is hazardous:
- Check whether the waste is excluded from the hazardous waste rules.
- Check whether it matches a listed hazardous waste.
- Check for hazardous characteristics, including toxicity. Test the waste, or apply knowledge of the materials and processes used.
New York requires generators to keep determination records for at least 3 years.
TCLP testing and limits
Tell the lab what you blasted and what might be in the debris. Use representative samples. Agree on the sampling plan with the lab, DEC, and the receiving site before collecting.
A waste is hazardous for toxicity if its TCLP extract meets or exceeds any limit in 40 CFR 261.24. The metals most relevant to coating debris are:
| Contaminant | EPA waste code | Limit (mg/L) |
|---|---|---|
| Arsenic | D004 | 5.0 |
| Barium | D005 | 100.0 |
| Cadmium | D006 | 1.0 |
| Chromium | D007 | 5.0 |
| Lead | D008 | 5.0 |
| Mercury | D009 | 0.2 |
| Selenium | D010 | 1.0 |
| Silver | D011 | 5.0 |
Passing TCLP addresses toxicity for the substances tested. It does not approve reuse or rule out other reasons a waste may be hazardous.
A BUD petition compares the waste’s chemical and physical data with criteria for the use. For fill or cover, pollutants must stay below Table 375-6.8(b) levels for residential use and groundwater protection, unless DEC accepts otherwise.
Finding a reuse destination
The predetermined list names specific materials and uses. For spent media, plan on a case-specific petition unless DEC confirms a listed use fits. Check any destination and proposed use with DEC before scheduling delivery.
When you talk to DEC, name the commercial product or raw material the media replaces. Get the user’s specifications and a contract or other proof of market. If reuse is not cleared, arrange disposal that fits the waste determination.
Worker protection
- Lead: removing lead-based coatings falls under OSHA’s lead in construction standard, 29 CFR 1926.62.
- Beryllium: coal slag contains trace beryllium. OSHA has identified abrasive blasting as an operation where trace amounts can still cause significant exposure. See 29 CFR 1926.1124 and OSHA’s beryllium standards page.
- Dust: control dust during collection, storage, and loading.
New York Public Employee Safety and Health (PESH) covers state and local government workers in New York. Federal OSHA covers private employers.
Storage and records
Keep the material contained, control dust and runoff, and label loads by job. Keep other wastes out. Storage before beneficial use may not exceed 365 days unless DEC approves a different period. Control run-on and run-off at storage areas.
Keep job records, data sheets, lab reports, the waste determination, the BUD letter, and the receiving site’s acceptance together. Record what ships and where it goes. Report the quantity used each year by March 1.
Before pickup
- Identify the abrasive, surfaces blasted, coatings, volume, moisture, and pickup location.
- Make the hazardous waste determination and complete the required tests.
- Choose a destination and get its material specifications.
- Confirm a predetermined BUD fits, or file a case-specific BUD petition with DEC.
- Get written acceptance and arrange pickup.
Talk to ARS about your material, location, volume, and test results. We can help you work through pickup and the next steps.
Common questions
Is a passing TCLP test enough?
No. It answers a toxicity question for the substances tested. The full waste determination, DEC approval, and the receiving site’s specifications still apply.
Can I use the original abrasive’s data sheet?
Keep it as background, but test or otherwise characterize the collected material. Blasting adds coatings and debris that the original data sheet does not cover.
Can the contractor or ARS file the petition?
Usually not. The generator or the potential end user signs. A third party may sign only if it will manage the material for the life of the BUD.
Can I use another project’s approval?
Usually not. A case-specific BUD covers the waste and use in the petition, under DEC’s conditions.
How long can spent media be stockpiled?
Storage before beneficial use may not exceed 365 days, unless DEC approves a different period.
How long does a BUD last?
A case-specific BUD lasts no more than five years. DEC can renew it on written request. A time- or quantity-limited BUD needs no renewal once the work is done and no more waste is proposed.
Rules and guidance
- DEC: Beneficial Use Determinations (BUDs)
- 6 NYCRR 360.12: Beneficial use
- 6 NYCRR 371.4: Lists of hazardous wastes
- 6 NYCRR 372.2: Standards applicable to generators of hazardous waste
- 40 CFR 262.11: Hazardous waste determination
- 40 CFR 261.24: Toxicity characteristic
- EPA Method 1311: TCLP
- EPA: Defining Hazardous Waste
- OSHA 29 CFR 1926.62: Lead in construction
- OSHA 29 CFR 1926.1124: Beryllium in construction
- New York Public Employee Safety and Health (PESH)